Our new book club, affectionately called TBR or The Book Readers, is trying a new format. Basically, we spin a wheel with the attendees’ names, then spin again for our predetermined group of genres. Whoever the wheel lands on chooses the book and writes the questions for our next Book of the Month.
I was chosen first and landed on Historical Fiction. However, I have grown pretty tired of the usual historical fiction centered on the world wars or early American history, so after some debate with myself and a quick check with the club, I picked a book that has been on my own “to be read” list for a while. The Tenant of Wildfell Hall by Anne Brontë. This bold but mostly unknown classic earned a 3.5 to 4 stars from me. Mostly it's considered Victorian Realism, however, in terms of the modern reader, we felt it was close enough to Historical Fiction.
Anne Brontë published under the name Acton Bell to avoid bias against women writers, and her work is now recognized as some of the earliest feminist writing in English literature. She died at only twenty-nine, yet her voice and the story remains strong and slightly modern.
This story begins when a widow arrives at Wildfell Hall with her son and a fierce desire for privacy. Gossip follows her immediately, springing from a mix of social control and boredom that still exists today. As we read Gilbert Markham’s letters, we see him refusing the rumors and grow determined to uncover the truth she is protecting.
What is she hiding? As a new, modern reader, has society changed in its view of women? Can men and women ever truly be friends or does someone always feel more deeply? Are young people even able to listen to the advice of their elders or must they experience life to understand it? These were the questions that came to me.
The book blends mystery, relationships, and the courage required to choose freedom, all within a gentle Gothic atmosphere.
Here is my honest confession. I enjoyed this far more than Wuthering Heights. Emily’s emotional storm has never been my favorite and I hated the characters. Anne’s characters felt more real because she was still great at developing characters and shocking readers. And although the 2005 Pride and Prejudice film with Keira Knightley is beloved by me, reading and listening to The Tenant of Wildfell Hall was more enjoyable than my experience with Pride and Prejudice. Anne’s pacing and style of using Gilbert's letters and Helen's diary made it feel like I'd stumbled across the Victorian TMZ.
This 1848 story has been adapted into several different lengths and that makes it perfect for readers who like something beefy or for those who just want a story without too much extra. If you decide to read this with a group, below are the questions I provided my club. [SPOILER ALERT!]
1. From 1-5 stars, what would you rate this book?
2. Why do you think Anne Brontë chose to use “the tenant” in the title, and what does it tell us about Helen’s place in society?
3. The story highlights the youthful infatuations of Helen and Gilbert along with the advice they received. If you could have shaken some sense into either of them, what simple piece of advice would you have shared?
4. After a night fueled by Arthur’s drinking and entitlement, Helen refused to indulge his mocking the next morning. As she walks quietly out of the room, he mutters “confounded slut.” It’s a small moment with big weight and is meant to shock Victorian readers. What was Anne trying to show by this sudden quip of cruelty in contrast to Helen’s gentleness?
5. When did Helen’s character and strength shine the most for you?
6. What was your favorite moment of the book, and which one made you think, “Absolutely not!”
7. Gilbert’s letter reveals his plan to play the long game as Helen’s “friend” until she catches feelings. Knowing his dishonestly, how did you feel about them becoming a couple in the end?
8. Do you think Anne Brontë risked her own reputation by challenging Victorian norms about marriage, women’s autonomy, and domestic abuse?
9. If Anne were sitting here with us tonight, what question would you most want to ask her?











